ArtWay

Iconoclasm is a genuine recognition of the power of the work of art. Nigel Halliday

Artists

Moore, Henry - VM - Nigel Halliday

Henry Moore: Reclining Figure

 Henry Moore Tate Britain Exhibition (2010)

by Nigel Halliday

The curators of the Henry Moore exhibition at Tate Britain (2010) had an overt agenda. They presented a narrative which holds that the huge popularity of Moore after the Second World War had the effect of domesticating his work and blinding us to his dark side. They wanted to re-establish the idea that Moore’s oeuvre was, in the words of Bryan Robertson, ‘anything but gentle’.

It took me a while to be convinced of the argument, partly because it depends on the commentary rather than the works. The exhibition itself contains many of the familiar, warmly human images of mothers and children, and ends with a glorious room of four huge reclining figures in elm wood.

Even the wartime drawings of figures sheltering from the Blitz in the underground, adduced here as an example of the artist’s edginess, seem to me perfectly sympathetic. The drawing of two sleeping figures, one with a hand innocently placed on the chest of the other in what is obviously a long and habitual closeness, seems engaging and comforting.

Nevertheless, the curators have got a point. With Moore’s success he came to be seen as the avuncular supplier of comforting human forms set in a landscape, or attractively tactile bronzes set in almost every urban space in the Western world. And in some people familiarity certainly bred contempt.

Moore, however, remained a deeply serious artist who claimed that a good work of art is ‘the expression of the significance of life’ and ‘a stimulation to greater effort in living’. On the bright side is the modernist thrill of freedom from old meanings and old forms, the optimism of creating a new humanity. Set against that are the darker implications of Darwin and Freud for what it means to be human, coupled with memories of the First World War as proof of what human beings are capable of. Moore himself served in the trenches, being gassed in 1917, and finding himself one of only 52 survivors from the original 400 men in his battalion.

Like many of his contemporaries Moore found a vocabulary for these sensibilities in non-Western art, from African, North and South American, Oceanic and palaeolithic sculpture. These meshed well with a Surrealist-inspired creation of forms that resisted rational explanation. He created sculptures, particularly in the early 1930s, that were at times with their distorted, hornlike heads and inscribed markings unsettling and threatening, and at other times defiantly hermetic.

What is odd about the argument of the exhibition, however, is that it invites us to look at the works more naturalistically than we have been taught to. In previous generations we had been encouraged to engage with sculptural form as an end in itself, divorced from naturalism and narrative. As Moore himself wrote in 1930 the sculpture that moved him most ‘has a life of its own, independent of the object it represents’. This exhibition invites us to look at the works much more literally as representations: these body parts are direct metaphors for a broken humanity, and these holes are all Freudian.

Of course, there is nothing funnier than watching art historians who are sure they have scented sexual references: no hole and no vertical line, however innocent, is allowed to go unnoticed – and of course, there are a lot of holes in a Henry Moore.

Nevertheless, even if at times the interpretation seems a little strained, it is interesting to see scholars rediscovering what they term the ‘abject’ in Moore’s depiction of the human, the brokenness, the mourning, and the focus on non-rational emotion. The search for meaning in a modernist world was neither triumphant nor triumphalist.

And yet, undercutting the argument of the exhibition, Moore has a redemptive side. While the Continental Surrealists created a closed world of sexual fantasy and hopeless anxiety, English Surrealists such as Moore and Paul Nash had a more romantic, almost pantheistic side to them, and tended to point outwards, towards a hope located in nature or in the humanity of the figure.

For all the edginess that this exhibition seeks to underline, it is still very life-affirming. Human beings are treated with nobility. The sculptor glories in the beauty of natural materials, which become a force in determining the final form. And the overt connections of figure and landscape create an atmosphere that is at least open and hopeful.

*******

Henry Moore: Reclining Figure, 1939; elmwood; 94 x 200.7 x 76.2 cm; Detroit Institute of Arts

This reflection was first published in Third Way, April 2010.

Henry Moore was born in Castleford, a small mining town in Yorkshire, in 1898. After training to be a teacher and serving in the British Army he studied at Leeds School of Art and then the Royal College of Art, London. By the 1950s Moore had begun to receive a number of international commissions. He continued working in sculpture, drawing, printmaking and textile design until his death in 1986. Moore was a pioneer and the first British artist to become a global star in his own lifetime. His work came to symbolise post-war modernism and can be said to have caused a British sculptural renaissance. https://henry-moore.org/

The Henry Moore Exhibition at Tate Britain ran from 24 February until 8 August, 2010. The exhibition presented more than 150 stone sculptures, wood carvings, bronzes and drawings. Highlights of the show included a group of key reclining figures carved in elm, which illustrate the development of this key image over his career. https://www.tate.org.uk/whats-on/tate-britain/henry-moore

Nigel Halliday is a British freelance art historian, lecturer and teacher. He studied History of Art at Cambridge University and the Courtauld Institute, London. He teaches the whole canon of Western art from Giotto onwards, but his main interests have been nineteenth- and twentieth-century art. He also has particular interest in Michelangelo and Rembrandt and the influence of Protestant belief on their work. He is a Research Fellow of the Kirby Laing Institute for Public Theology in Cambridge, England.  www.nigelhalliday.org

ArtWay Visual Meditation 13 August 2023