ArtWay

The artist is not a special kind of person. Every person is a special kind of artist. Eric Gill

Jusepe de Ribera: The Adoration of the Shepherds

ArtWay Visual Meditation December 11, 2022

www.artway.eu

Third Sunday of Advent

Jusepe de Ribera: The Adoration of the Shepherds

Making the Invisible Visible

by James Romaine

The work of the Spanish-born baroque artist Jusepe de Ribera (1591-1652) is characterized by a visual method of transformed naturalism. Uniting narrative and symbolism, Ribera translated a careful observation of nature into the material of paint as a means of making the invisible visible.

In The Adoration of the Shepherds, completed just two years before his death and now in the collection of the Louvre Museum, Ribera applied this method of transformed naturalism to a sacred narrative motif. This 1650 painting unites the observation of nature with sacred symbolism to focus his presumed Catholic Reformation viewer on the devotional meaning of the nativity.

Since Ribera’s creative process began with a study of observation, our process engaging his work should also begin with a careful examination of his motif and structure. Ribera’s design connects our eye, the process by which we read the image, and our imagination, how we interpret what we see. His composition unites a complex arrangement of figures, so that we read the entire narrative motif as single devotional moment, fixed on the infant Christ.

As we begin reading this composition in the lower left, our attention is drawn toward the central figure of Christ. The diagonal pose of his body directs us toward the upper right. His body is posed at a diagonal in one direction. However, the expression on his face is in the opposite direction. If we draw a line from Christ’s feet to his head and another line through his eyes, these lines from an X. As the visual and spiritual focal point, towards which everything in Ribera’s painting converges, the figure of Christ is the center that unites the composition.

Stationed protectively over the manger is Joseph. Gazing affectionately at Christ, Joseph’s arms are crossed in reverence. He is a model for Ribera’s viewer of faithful devotion. Continuing our lower-left-to-upper-right reading of the composition, the woman holding a basket in the background stops us and redirects us toward the left.

Across the background, there are two scenes that, in sequence, depict the angels’ announcement to the shepherds. This distant landscape forms a visual bridge over the top of the composition. However, so that we don’t exit the composition’s upper left, there is a strategically placed diagonal line, camouflaged within the motif as a beam of wood. This sends our attention us back in the direction of Christ.

Even the shepherd with his hat raised is a significant part of our being led through the composition. The raised hat is both part of the narrative and a part of the composition. But both direct our attention and devotion toward the figure of infant in the manger.

A narrative image with a devotional purpose, Jusepe de Ribera’s Adoration of the Shepherds is a carefully designed motif that draws the viewer from every compositional direction toward the figure of Christ. This makes us a participant in drawing closer to the infant in the manger.

Having surveyed the overall devotion-oriented composition of Ribera’s The Adoration of the Shepherds, let’s study some of its details. Ribera created amazing illusions of a complex range of textures. Just look across the kneeling shepherd at the right, from his ruddy face, to his beard, to fleece he wears, to the layers of his tattered jacket. Ribera has lined up a sumptuous sequence of fabrics, colors, and textures. This rustic figure, as well as the rock on which he kneels, anticipates the 19th-century realism of Gustave Courbet. It is no wonder that Ribera has proudly signed his name on this rock.

The hay spills out of a partly broken manger, a detail that gives visual authenticity to the motif of Christ’s humble birth. But this is where Ribera’s method pivots from what we can see to the visualization of a sacred realm that is beyond what we can see. This battered crib reminded Ribera’s Catholic Reformation viewer that Christ had been born into a world in need of spiritual repair.

Ribera depicts a devotional moment that is full of sacred symbolism. Perhaps the most obvious example of Ribera’s combination of naturalism and symbolism is the bound lamb in the foreground. It might be that the shepherds have brought this lamb, perhaps their only wealth, as an offering to Christ. However, this bound lamb also evokes the sacrifice that Christ will make on behalf of these saintly herdsmen.

The other animals also support Ribera’s method of making sacred symbolism more believable through visual naturalism. An ox nudges its nose into the manger. And the donkey at the left has an especially alert expression. While the ox and the ass are fairly common in depictions of the Adoration of the Shepherds, Ribera’s donkey evidences a remarkable degree of spiritual consciousness. These animals evoke what the Jewish prophet Isaiah wrote. “The ox knows its master, the donkey its master’s crib, but Israel does not know, my people do not understand” (Isaiah 1:3).  

Fitting with Ribera’s Catholic Reformation purpose, the Virgin Mary is given special attention. A simple maiden, she is beautiful, without being idealized. Throughout his career, Ribera tended toward rustic colors, and this work amply demonstrates how much he could accomplish within a narrow range of tones. Ribera would only occasionally and strategically include brilliantly saturated colors, such as the lapis blue of Virgin’s cloak, as means of focusing the viewer’s attention.

Jusepe de Ribera’s Adoration of the Shepherds demonstrates his capacity to visually unite naturalism and symbolism. The naturalism makes the symbolism immediate and believable. The symbolism gives the naturalism a sense of spiritual meaning and identity. This work visualizes a scene of recognition and devotion with the purpose of instilling these in the viewer. As we begin the Advent season, may this painting orient and focus our spiritual attention.

*******

Jusepe de Ribera: Adoration of the Shepherds, 1650, oil on canvas, 239 x 181 cm. The Louvre, Paris.

Jusepe de Ribera (1591-1652) was a Spanish painter and printmaker, noted for his baroque dramatic realism and his depictions of religious and mythological subjects. He was born in Spain but spent most of his life in Italy. Little is known of his life in Spain, though he is said by the painter and biographer Antonio Palomino de Castro y Velasco to have received his first training there under Francisco Ribalta (1565 –1628). It is not known when he went to Italy, but there is evidence that as a young man he worked in Parma and Rome. In 1616 he married in Naples, then under Spanish rule, where he remained the rest of his life. In 1626 he signed as a member of the Roman Academy of St. Luke and in 1631 as a knight of the Papal Order of Christ, although he always retained his Spanish identity.

James Romaine is Professor of Art History at Lander University in Greenwood, SC, USA. He is the co-founder of the Association of Scholars of Christianity in the History of Art (ASCHA). His publications include Art as Spiritual Perception: Essays in Honor of E. John Walford (Crossway) and Beholding Christ and Christianity in African American Art (Penn State University Press, 2018). His videos can be seen on YouTube at SeeingArtHistory: https://youtu.be/xbcjY8hOCoY.

The video for this Sunday of Romaine’s Advent at the Louvre can be seen here. It is about The Holy Family with Saint Anne by Rembrandt van Rijn.

*******

ART NEWS INTERNATIONAL

NEW ICONS FROM UKRAINE – Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary in Charlotte is delighted to host East Meets West, a visual art exhibit paying tribute to eight innovative women icon makers of Ukraine, a land where the Latin and Byzantine worlds collide and converge. These eight artists, students of a new school of iconography in the West Ukrainian cultural center of Lviv, have achieved recognition in a religious art genre traditionally dominated by men. Respectful of the theological and artistic canons of iconography, they experiment with different mediums, unusual painting techniques, and color palettes to create contemporary variations on time-honored themes. Read John Kohan’s story of discovering these iconographers in an essay titled On the Border of East and West: Searching for Icons in Lviv in Image Magazine.

CHRISTMAS IN ART BY NIGEL HALLIDAY – Christmas in art talk on Sunday evening 11th December, 6.45 pm UK time. We will look at a range of paintings, but this year I will be spending quite a bit of time talking about Hugo van der Goes' Adoration of the shepherds, aka The Portinari altarpiece, which is rich and beautiful, and has the unusual boast of being the largest Flemish painting in Florence, and pretty much the largest Flemish painting of its age. If you would like to attend in person, join us at Widcombe Baptist Church, Pulteney Rd (South), Bath BA2 4JR. Drinks and nibbles from 6.15 p.m. Talk starts at 6.45. If you would like to attend online, search for 'Widcombe Baptist Church Youtube’ or 'Widcombe Baptist Church livestream’.

BILL CROSS ARTLYST INTERVIEW – Winslow Homer: American Passage, an interview with biographer Bill Cross. The author of the biography Winslow Homer: American Passage, Bill Cross, is an independent scholar and a consultant to art and history museums. He is an author who tells stories of Americans whose works are known but whose lives are not. In 2019, he curated Homer at the Beach, A Marine Painter’s Journey, 1869-1880, for which he also wrote the catalogue, at the Cape Ann Museum. He also wrote about Winslow Homer for ArtWay. Read more

SCOTTISH MORPHE CONFERENCE – 18 February, 9 h, Leith School of Art, 25 N Jct St, Edinburgh: Scottish Morphe in person Interface Conference. With speakers (Deborah Lewer and Carol Marples), workshops, live performances and more. Save the date and make plans to join us at Leith School of Art in Edinburgh. https://www.morphearts.org/whats-on/interface-conference-2023

MALCOLM GUITE IN CONVERSATION – In the online conversation “Waiting on the Word,” poet-priest Malcolm Guite talks about imagination, metaphor, how poetry can enlarge our prayers, and how God works in the darkness. He also reads two poems from his O Antiphons series, which can be found in Waiting on the Word: A Poem a Day for Advent, Christmas, and Epiphany.

SEATED MADONNA NURSING BY SUOR PLAUTILLA NELLI – 1 February, 7pm on Zoom: Candlemas Eve Lecture in Honour of the late Dr Cathy Oakes. Art historian Dr Cecelia Dorger, who is an adjunct professor at the Mount St. Mary Seminary and School of Theology in Cincinnati, USA, will deliver an online Candlemas Eve lecture in honour of the late Dr Cathy Oakes. Her presentation, entitled "Soul Sisters: Late Medieval and Renaissance Nuns’ Devotion to the Nursing Madonna Image", will analyse the drawing entitled Seated Madonna Nursing (Uffizi Gallery) by Suor Plautilla Nelli (1524 –1588), known as the first Renaissance female painter. She will discuss the questions raised by this exquisite (but rebellious) image which hung in convents across late Medieval and Renaissance Europe. https://www.marianstudies.ac.uk/post/forthcoming-events?postId=1acf7f2e-3653-4875-a4af-bb8e745cf2a4  

PISS CHRIST – Andres Serrano: Piss Christ Immortalised On The Blockchain With New NFT. The Revd Jonathan Evens about Andres Serrano’s work, “Among religious people, mental shifts are only made by reinterpreting the holy texts and, in this scenario, developing a theology of the Other, which involves seeing God’s face in strangers. An example of how this kind of dialogue can begin, taken from within the Christian tradition, involves that of those Christians who seek to censor or attack Andres Serrano’s Piss Christ on the basis of blasphemy. Such views cannot be countered or changed by arguments in the public square about the value of free speech, as free speech is viewed as a license for blasphemy. In this context, liberal arguments about free speech simply reinforce the religious sense of being under attack. However, it is possible to engage in a debate, based on Christian language and doctrine, about the nature of Christ’s incarnation of which, by submerging an image of Christ in human detritus, Piss Christ actually enables profound Christian reflection. Engaging in this dialogue on these terms, therefore, holds potential for the shifting of perspectives and understandings.” Read more

ADVENT BILDIMPULS ÜBER MARIA – Uli Winkler: Maria. Eine beeindruckende Arbeit, die zu adventlichem Innehalten und zur Einstimmung auf das zu Erwartende oder Kommende einlädt. Lese hier

GENESIS IN REGENSBURG – Die multimediale Licht - und Videoinstallation im Kirchenraum St. Ulrich in Regensburg (beim Dom). Die 25-minütige geniale Videoinstallation GENESIS entführt musikalisch und visuell in eine neue Dimension aus Farben, Licht und Klängen – von der Erschaffung des Lichts bis zur Geburt der Pflanzenwelt. Bis 15. Januar. Begrenzte Besucherzahl pro Aufführung – Ticketbuchung erwünscht! https://www.genesis-regensburg.de/

LARMES DE JOIE EN PARIS – « Larmes de joie » de Benoît Dutour exposées à la Madeleine à Paris pour Noël 2022. Une œuvre monumentale qui joue avec la lumière :« Larmes de joie » est présentée au sein de l’église de la Madeleine, pour fêter Noël, du 3 décembre 2022 au 29 janvier 2023. Pour Narthex, Sylvie Bethmont-Gallerand a dialogué avec son auteur, l’artiste plasticien Benoît Dutour. Plus

For more exhibitions, lectures, conferences etc., click here

ArtWay is a website with resources for congregations and individuals concerned about linking art and faith.

ARTWAY: OPENING EYES, HEARTS AND MINDS